StockCentral
»
StockCentral
»
The Infirmary
»
StockCentral TakeStock: incorrect Total Return
Rank: Advanced Member
Posts: 105
|
http://www.stockcentral.com/tools/takestock/tabid/158/language/en-US/Default.aspx/ctl/return/mid/735/Default.aspx, says the following under the heading "Total Return at the Buy price" ...
If you buy Quality Systems, Incorporate at $46, you could realize an annual total return of 13.2% over the next five years.
However, considering the Potential High Price of $85.4, 13.2% is the return from price appreciation alone, ignoring the dividend yield (about 2%). "Total Return at the Buy price", by definition, must be at least 14.9%.
-Jim Thomas
|
|
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member
Posts: 262
|
I put an SSG on the qsii forum that shows a buy up to approx $39. If you bought today you would need an18% return just to get to $46
|
|
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member
Posts: 105
|
I assume your SSG uses different judgment than TakeStock (your high price is $76.3).
I'm pointing out an inconsistent formula in the online Take Stock.
-Jim Thomas
|
|
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member
Posts: 262
|
True Jim but it would seem my estimates are even more conservative than TS which is tradtionally ultra conservative. I was using 15% as estimated growth. I understand your note on needing the 14.9% return to double in five years. But I don't see how they would ever get a 3/1 U/D ratio with a buy up to $46. Mine was 3.3/1 at a price of $37.80
|
|
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member
Posts: 105
|
> But I don't see how they would ever get a 3/1 U/D ratio with a buy up to $46.
TakeStock is using a yield supported low price of $32.9, rather than its PExEPS forecast low price of $16.56. That's how it gets a 25% risk ratio (aka 3-to-1 US/DS) with a buy price of $46.
Take a look at the "Risk" and "Price Analysis" sections at the "TSSW Back" link from TakeStock.
Note that the formula for Yield Supported Low Price in TakeStock is very different than that on the SSG (and the results of the two formulas are very different for QSII). If you want to discuss the relative merits of the two formulas, I suggest that you start a different message thread.
-Jim Thomas
|
|
|
|
StockCentral
»
StockCentral
»
The Infirmary
»
StockCentral TakeStock: incorrect Total Return
Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.